Skeptical about Alkaline Water and Water Ionizer Machines?

After 10 Years in the Alkaline Water Business...I wouldn't be in business if it was a placebo.

 

I hope you went to the Alkaline Water Testimonials link first. Please read the personal letters from doctors and people who have taken the time to write about their experiences. It's difficult to argue with them.

The following table was from a page that tries to "scientifically" debunk alkaline water and other claims. He has his right to his own opinion, but I seriously believe he has been sold a bill of goods by some anti-homeopathic group.

The hype
The science
Ionized alkaline water is grouped together in smaller clusters of 5-6 water molecules instead of the 10-13 found in tap water. This makes it "micro-clustered", meaning it will be more quickly and easily absorbed, and will hydrate the tissues more effectively.

The hexagonal molecular structure resulting from electrolysis is what makes ionized water wetter than tap or bottled water. These smaller "hexagons" of water molecules are half as large as the molecular chains that come out of the faucet, and permeate cellular membranes quicker so that Alkaline Water is more hydrating and quicker to refresh after strenuous exercise.

This is correct. You can measure cluster sizes with NMR, you can also measure surface tension in dynes, with appropriate instruments. You can taste the water is different. A double blind test with 100 subjects: ask them to try city tap water and the same water ionized. I bet that a statistically significant number will say that the ionized water is lighter, more easily absorbed. What could account for this, it's the same water?

Alkaline water

  • Increases energy, decreases recovery time and  improves capacity for aerobic activities.

  • "Slows the aging process, lowers blood pressure and helps the heart work less." 

  • Neutralizes and flushes toxins and acidic waste from your body. Your body can focus on achieving optimal health.

  • The electrolysis process rearranges healthy minerals that are native to your tap water according to their electrical charge. As a result, alkaline ionized water contains essential calcium, magnesium, sodium, and potassium minerals in a form that can be assimilated.

  • Cancer does not thrive in an oxygenated and alkaline environment while health does.

These statements may be true and they are freely given by people who gave their testimonial. I don't know what statistical evidence there is, but it would make sense as water is needed for every bodily function and most of us are dehydrated.

Our bodies are 75% water and our brain is 85%.  Don't you think the brain has to adjust and regulate bodily functions from the hydration aspect alone?

The brain has to compensate for dehydration. It could be argued that all these are possible benefits from drinking water and dehydration is the root of all disease. If you look at the many studies, and the many health and anti-aging literature, you have to conclude that it is possible that alkaline water may be helpful.

The last one was proved by Dr Warburg, for which he was awarded the Nobel Prize for Medicine see his paper 'The Metabolism of Tumors', London, 1930.

Beneficial uses of acidic water:

  • Natural astringent for improving complexions.  It removes skin oil and greasy dirt without harsh chemicals.

  • Natural hair conditioner.

  • Highly antiseptic for cuts, abrasions, and wounds

  • Soaking in warm acidic ionized water improves healing from athletes foot, rashes, nail fungus infections and insect bites

Check out the Testimonial page

There is no scientific evidence to support the assertions about the existence of water clusters or its beneficial effects on tissue hydration.

That's what the Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) measures.

If water is more hydrating (as the measured smaller clusters would suggest) then it will reach the cells, so benefit the cell, otherwise it will by-pass the cells and provide the cell with no hydration or nutrients or assist with the waste removal.

See comments to the left about clusters.

The diagram on the left is incorrect and misleading. There is no way that H2O molecules in liquid water can be stabilized or retained in the hexagonal configuration shown.

It is no where stated the structure is a stabilized configuration; it is dynamic, moving configuration, like a molecular dance. How can anything in water be stable? Japanese and Korean scientists are not the fools that this person appears to make them look!

There is no credible scientific evidence for any of these statements, which you will find only on Web sites promoting commercial products.

I don't think I need to read about unreadable 'credible scientific evidence' in a scientific journal before I decide whether or not to drink pure alkaline water. Just a little common sense will do. People have been drinking alkaline water from mountain springs and glacier water sources for thousands of years, modern science is barely a hundred years old. There are Chinese writings going back to 5000 years ago about Taoist masters that lived on high mountain air and spring water and had life spans of several hundred years.

There is no 'credible scientific evidence' that proves that McDonalds fast food is bad for your health or makes you fat.

All the 'credible scientific evidence' says that McDonalds food is good for you, and there are many people that have been made bankrupt for saying that it's not.

A Whopper (a chemist will tell you) has x grams of protein, y grams carbs, + a full list of nutrients - a chemically balanced meal in fact. A cola has lots of sugar that you need for energy they will tell you.

Does this mean that we should keep eating it?

Claims such as these are widely propagated by water ionizer hucksters without any supporting evidence. If you really want to sample the "benefits" of acidic water, try a dilute solution of vinegar or almost any fruit juice.

You can test these things, for example acid water is an antiseptic.  Plus why do these doctors support alkaline water and why have their patients been helped with water?

I have also been in this business for 10 years and have seen some wonderful things happed to people and animals drinking this water.  Read more about, why I am I promote water ionizer machines.

Many people wonder which ionizer machine they should choose and I've written some information about, "Help me chose an ionizer machine."

Alkaline Water Research

Impairment of Malignant Tumor Phenotypes by Electrolyzed Reduced Water. Department of Genetic Resources Technology, Graduate of Kyushu University.

Electrolyzed-reduced water scavenges active oxygen species protection DNA from oxidative damage. Institute of Cellular Regulation Technology, Kyushu University

Acidic Water Research

Treatment of infectious skin defects or ulcers with electrolyzed strong acid aqueous solution. Department of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, Tokyo Metropolitan Police Hospital

Inactivation of Escherichia coli and Listeriaon plastic kitchen cutting boards by electrolyzed water. Department of Animal Science, University of Connecticut

Observation on the effect of disinfection to HBsAg by electrolyzed oxidizing water. Nosocomial Infection Department China-Japan Friendship Hospital

Fundamental studies on crop disease control by spraying electrolyzed strong acid water. Graduate School Science & Technology, China University Matsudo Japan.

Effectiveness of electrolyzed oxidized water irrigation in a burn-wound infection model. Department of Emergency and Critical Care Medicine, Akita University School of Medicine, Japan.

Effectiveness of electrolyzed water as a sanitizer for treating different surfaces. Dept. of Food Science & Technology, University of Georgia

Preliminary study of microbiocide effect and its mechanism of electrolyzed oxidizing water. Institute of Epidemiology and Microbiology, Chinese Academy of Preventive Medicine.

Here is Google's Search Engine -  Check these out for Yourself
Custom Search

Calcium Leeching Research

Chronic Acidosis-Induced Alteration in Bone Bicarbonate and Phosphate. Nephrology Unit, Department of Medicine, University of Rochester School of Medicine.

 
 

Here are books about Alkaline health and Acidic problems

Alkalize or Die
The world is facing the largest health crisis in recorded history. Dr. Baroody's research and clinical findings indicate that illness and disease are directly linked to over acidity in the system. The polluted air we breathe, the chemicals in our food and water we ingest are just part of the problem. Stress on all levels - physical, emotional, mental, and even spiritual cause the body to overproduce acid wastes, upsetting our delicate alkaline/acid balance.

Your Body's Many Cries for Water
As a result of extensive research into the role of water in the body, the author, a medical doctor, believes that he has found chronic dehydration to be the cause of many conditions including asthma, allergies, arthritis, angina, migraine headaches, hypertension, raised cholesterol, chronic fatigue syndrome, multiple sclerosis, depression, and diabetes in the elderly.

You can also go to my AlkalizerH2O Blog or Alkaline Forum sections of my website and read about a lot of information as well.

 

If you like what you read, please Social Bookmark this page.

 
 
 
 
Copyright 2005-2010 AlkalizerH2O.com and TheAlkalizer.com